Blog
Homemade gummies: recipes, tips and cooking secrets
Homemade gummy sweets are the perfect proof that you can make delicious treats at home. Just a few ingredients, a little patience and your favourite moulds – that’s all it takes to have colourful, chewy treats on the table, with ingredients you’ve chosen yourself.
Unlike many shop-bought jelly sweets, homemade ones allow you to choose natural ingredients, experiment with flavours and adapt the recipe to suit your needs. You can use fruit juice, berry purées, honey or other favourite sweeteners, whilst recipes using agar are also suitable for those looking for a plant-based alternative.
In this article, you’ll find three recipes for homemade jelly sweets, learn how to achieve a springy texture, find out what ingredients you’ll need, and discover how to store the finished sweets properly.
Why make homemade gummies at home?
Homemade gummies give you complete control over the ingredients: no artificial colours, preservatives or synthetic flavours, which are typical of the products on the shelves. Instead of refined sugar, you can choose natural sweeteners: honey, maple syrup or agave syrup.
This is especially true for parents. Knowing every ingredient, they can offer their children a sweet treat without remorse. And the flavour possibilities are practically endless: fresh strawberries, blueberry puree, cherry juice or unexpected combinations with citrus.
Market acceptance confirms that quality gummies made from natural ingredients are not a utopia. „Brothers” Honey” guminukai „Broliai lokiai”, made from fruit juices and honey, won a gold medal at the „Choose Lithuanian 2022″ exhibition. This shows that natural ingredients and great taste go well together.
Ingredients for homemade gummies: gelatine, agar, sweeteners and moulds
Every recipe for homemade jelly sweets is based on three groups of ingredients: a gelling agent (gelatine, agar or pectin), a liquid (fruit juice, purée) and a sweetener (honey, sugar, syrup).
Gelatine, agar and pectin: which to choose and in what proportions?
Gelatine is the most versatile choice, providing the elastic, chewy texture of a real gum. The chewy consistency requires approximately 18-20 g of gelatine in 250 ml of liquid. The type of gelatine is also important: granular and sheet gelatine differ in bloom value (setting strength), so the final texture is directly dependent on adherence to proportions.
Agar Suitable for vegans and vegetarians, but the products will be firmer and more fragile than if chewed. Proportion: 1 teaspoon agar powder in 250 ml liquid.
Pectin least suitable for gum trees. It works better in marmalade-type sweets, so gelatine or agar is recommended for beginners.
Sweeteners for homemade gum: honey, sugar and syrups
White sugar is the cheapest option, giving the classic texture and sweetness of gum, but without any additional benefit to the body.
Honey acts as a natural sweetener with a warm, distinctive flavour. Different types of honey impart different nuances, so it’s worth choosing according to the desired final flavour. When experimenting with recipes, you can also add a small amount of bee pollen to the gummy mixture, but as it has a distinctive flavour, it’s best to try a smaller batch first.
Maple syrup and agave syrup are used in similar proportions to honey, but each adds a distinct character: maple syrup is caramel-like, agave is more neutral. Gummies made completely without sweetener will be sour, so at least 2 tablespoons sweetener is needed even in the healthiest version.
Homemade gum recipes: classic, sugar-free and vegan
Below are three recipe variations: classic with gelatine, sugar-free with honey and vegan with agar.
Classic homemade juice gummies with gelatine
Mix 250 ml of natural fruit juice (apple, cherry or orange), 18-20 g of gelatine and 2-3 tablespoons of sugar or honey. Heat the juice over low heat, add the gelatine and stir until completely dissolved. Do not boil, as the gelatine loses its firming properties.
Pour the prepared mixture into silicone moulds and refrigerate 2-4 hours, until the gummies are completely set.
Place them in the freezer for 10-15 minutes before removing them from the tins. Once chilled, the gummies shrink and detach more easily from the silicone walls.
Homemade sugar-free gummies: with honey or maple syrup
Mix 250 ml of fruit puree (strawberry or blueberry), 18-20 g of gelatine and 2-3 tablespoons of honey or maple syrup. Heat the puree, dissolve the gelatine and pour into silicone moulds. Refrigerate for 2-4 hours.
As well as acting as a sweetener, honey gives a warm, multi-layered flavour, so no additional sugar is needed. The result is most pronounced when you choose quality natural honey. Maple syrup is suitable for those who want a caramel shade and the proportions remain the same.
Vegan homemade gummies with agar
Mix 250 ml of juice or fruit puree, 1 teaspoon of agar powder and 2 tablespoons of agave syrup. Unlike gelatine, agar agar needs to be cooked: bring the mixture to the boil and cook for 2-3 minutes, stirring continuously, until the agar agar has completely dissolved.
Pour into silicone moulds and leave to set at room temperature or in the fridge.
The texture will be different from gelatine gummies: the agar version will be firmer and more brittle, like marmalade. Chewy elasticity is not expected, but it is the best plant-based option for those who avoid animal products.
How to achieve a chewy gum texture: tips from practice
The chewy, elastic texture depends on three factors: the amount of gelatine, the type of syrup and the drying after setting.
The proportion of gelatine makes all the difference. For a standard jelly, 10-12 g in 250 ml of liquid is sufficient, but for chewing gum you need 18-20 g or more. The more gelatine, the stiffer and more elastic the result.
Glucose or corn syrup is not just a sweetener. It is the syrup that gives that chewy „pull” sensation of store-bought gummies. Without it, the texture will remain like plain jelly, no matter how much gelatine you use.
And now for the secret that most recipes don’t mention. After 2-4 hours in the fridge, the gummies need drying 24-72 hours at room temperature on a wire rack or baking paper. This process removes surface moisture and produces a firm, slightly springy consistency. The best texture is achieved after 3-5 days in the open air.
Extra trick: a pinch of citric acid gives a brighter taste and slightly improves the final texture.
Storing homemade gum: how long and how to store correctly?
Homemade gummies keep in the fridge 1-2 weeks, if stored in a tightly sealed container or covered with cling film. In the freezer, the shelf life is extended to 2 months and thawing at room temperature is sufficient.
It is not worth leaving gelatine gummies in the room for a long time, as gelatine softens with heat and moisture.
You will recognise damaged gum by its sticky surface, unwanted smell or mould. If you notice any of these signs, do not use the whole batch.
The gummies can be coated with a thin layer of beeswax to help them detach from the moulds.
Frequently asked questions about pet gummies
Why are my homemade gummies too soft and jelly-like?
The most common cause is too little gelatine or a complete absence of syrup in the recipe. Increase the proportion of gelatine to 20 g in 250 ml of liquid, add at least a couple of tablespoons of glucose syrup and, most importantly, dry the gummies on a grill at room temperature for 24 to 72 hours after refrigeration.
How long can I keep homemade gummies?
The homemade gummies will keep for 1-2 weeks in the fridge and up to 2 months in the freezer when tightly sealed. The gelatine softens quickly at room temperature and is not suitable for longer storage without refrigeration.
Is it possible to make homemade gummies without gelatine?
Yes, agar agar is a plant-based alternative suitable for vegans. Agar gummies will be firmer and more crumbly and less chewy than gelatinous ones. The proportions and cooking process vary, so refer to the vegan recipe links above.
What are the best moulds for homemade gummies?
Silicone rubber moulds are the best choice as the flexible material allows easy removal without deformation. Silicone moulds for ice cream or chocolate are also suitable. Before pouring the mixture, brush the mould with a thin layer of coconut or neutral oil.
How are homemade gummies healthier than store-bought ones?
At home, you have full control over the ingredients: no artificial colours, preservatives or synthetic flavours. Refined sugar can be replaced by natural sweeteners such as quality honey or maple syrup. Sugar alcohols and artificial additives are often used in store-bought gum that are simply not present in the homemade version.
Making homemade gummies is even more enjoyable when you use really good quality ingredients. „Brolių medus offers natural Lithuanian honey, which is the perfect sugar substitute for gum recipes, and their gold-medal-winning Broliai lokiai gummies can be both an inspiration and a tasty snack for those who want to try a taste of expertly crafted flavour.
Whether you’re making gummy sweets for the first time or are already experimenting with flavours, high-quality ingredients determine the final result. Pop into the ‘Brothers Honey’ shop and choose honey, natural gummy sweets or other bee products, such as bee bread, which will help you discover more authentic flavours. For those interested in a wider selection of bee products, it’s also worth exploring royal jelly, which stands out for its unique composition and method of use.